JH-600, JH-325 or JH-WH3364: A Mill Buyer's Comparison
JH-600, JH-325 or JH-WH3364: A Mill Buyer's Comparison
Three surface sizing grades, one paper machine, and three technical data sheets that were never written to the same basis. That is the usual starting position when a mill shortlists JH-600, JH-325 and JH-WH3364 from Qingzhou Jinhao New Material Co., Ltd. (JHDA). The comparison that decides the purchase is not which sheet looks strongest. It is which grade can be verified against the mill's own furnish, size-press configuration and wet-end chemistry, and at what cost in trial time and documentation.
This buyer comparison is built from that position. It separates what is verifiable about the three grades from what is not, explains what each specification parameter actually controls on the machine, applies the result to acidic, neutral and alkaline papermaking, and sets out the acceptance criteria and trial design that settle the choice. Where the public record does not contain a value, the gap is named rather than filled with a plausible number.
The comparison problem: three grades, three measurement bases
Specification comparisons fail in four predictable places. Solids may be quoted as delivered or as active content, which changes the dry-on-dry dosage by a large multiple. Viscosity may be measured at a different solids level, temperature or spindle speed than the one the mill will run at the size press. pH may be quoted on the concentrate rather than at the concentration the mill actually circulates. Dosage may be expressed as a percentage of dry pulp, as kilograms per ton of paper, or as wet addition per litre of size-press liquor, and only one of those maps to the mill's cost account.
Two consequences follow for a three-way shortlist. First, the grades should be compared as delivered cost per ton of saleable paper at a fixed performance target, not as price per kilogram. Second, every supplier figure, including JHDA's own, is a starting hypothesis for a mill trial rather than an acceptance result. A comparison that ignores this produces a decision the mill has to re-run anyway.
What is verifiable about JH-600, JH-325 and JH-WH3364 today
The clearest verifiable fact in this shortlist is JH-325's chemistry. JHDA's published portfolio describes "JH-611 and JH-325 anionic styrene-acrylic surface sizing agent", which fixes two buyer-relevant attributes: the product family is styrene-acrylic surface sizing (SAE), and the ionic character is anionic. Those two attributes alone determine how the grade should be handled beside cationic wet-end additives, how it behaves inside an anionic size-press starch film, and which dilution-water quality it tolerates.
JH-WH3364 is presented as a dual-function composite intended to cover both internal and surface sizing duties in one product. JH-600 is the third grade in the shortlist. For all three, the public record assessed for this article does not contain model-level solids, pH, viscosity, starch-compatibility, foaming or shear data. That is not unusual for paper chemicals, but it is precisely why an acceptance decision should not be built on a comparison table assembled from marketing pages.
Portfolio context is verifiable and relevant, because a surface sizing choice interacts with the rest of the wet end. JHDA's listed range covers AKD neutral sizing emulsion, JH-611 and JH-325 anionic styrene-acrylic surface sizing agent, rosin sizing agent, an anti-humidity sizing auxiliary, wax emulsions, SBR latex, the JH-1216 dry strength agent, JH-1201 PAE wet strength resin, optical brightening agents, defoamers, dryer release agents, stickies control enzymes, biocides, deodorants, sludge encapsulants, and water vapour barrier and food-grade hydrophobic coatings for packaging paper.
Management-system evidence is also documented at company level: ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 certification, SGS product compliance test reports, CAS registration and GHS hazard labelling, and IMDG-compliant shipping documentation. The documented minimum order quantity is 1 MT. The company states SGS food-contact testing for packaging-paper chemicals; food-contact suitability still has to be confirmed per formulation and per destination market, because a product description is not a regulatory determination.
| Parameter | Why it decides acceptance | Status in the available public record |
|---|---|---|
| Chemistry and ionic character | Governs starch and wet-end compatibility, dilution route and charge management | JH-325: anionic styrene-acrylic, stated in the company portfolio. JH-600 and JH-WH3364: request in writing |
| Total and active solids | Sets dry-on-dry dosage, add-on control and freight cost per active tonne | Not published for any of the three grades |
| pH | Sets the handling window, corrosion risk and compatibility envelope | Not published |
| Viscosity | Sets metering, film uniformity and misting at the size press | Not published; any future value must state temperature, spindle and solids |
| Starch compatibility | Sets size-press liquor stability, deposit risk and viscosity drift | Not published |
| Foaming and shear stability | Sets pump behaviour, filtration, pinholing and film defects | Not published; test method required, not a descriptive claim |
| Compliance documents | Gate for regulated and food-contact markets | ISO 9001, ISO 14001 and SGS reports stated by the company |
| Product-family capacity | Sets supply continuity for a contracted grade | Published company-wide capacity statements differ between company sources and are not split by product family; request product-level capacity and utilisation |
Six parameters that decide whether a surface sizing grade runs well
The explanations below are general to surface sizing chemistry rather than specific to one grade. They are the questions to put to JH-600, JH-325 and JH-WH3364 in identical form, so that the answers can be compared.
Solids content
Solids content decides how much water is being shipped and how much active film-former reaches the sheet. Two grades at the same price per kilogram but different solids can differ substantially in cost per ton of paper. Ask for total solids, active solids and the test method, then convert every quotation to a dry-on-dry basis before comparing. A grade quoted on a delivered-product basis against one quoted on an active basis is not a comparison at all.
pH and ionic character
pH defines the handling window and the compatibility envelope. An anionic styrene-acrylic grade such as JH-325 should not share a dilution or feed line with a strongly cationic wet-end additive, because charge neutralisation produces deposits and loses sizing efficiency. pH also affects pump and piping materials and the stability of the size-press starch blend. Ask for pH on the concentrate and at the concentration the mill actually circulates.
Viscosity
Viscosity is only meaningful with its conditions attached: solids, temperature, spindle and speed. On a film press or size press, viscosity controls film uniformity, pick-up and the tendency to mist or throw. A grade that meters cleanly at the trial concentration but thickens on recirculation shows up as streaks and edge build-up. Ask for a viscosity curve across the mill's dilution range rather than a single point value.
Starch compatibility
Surface sizing is normally applied with starch, so compatibility means more than mixing without visible separation. It means no gelling, no phase separation, no viscosity drift across a shift, and no deposit on the size-press rolls. Ask for compatibility data with the specific starch the mill cooks, whether oxidised, ethylated or enzyme-converted, at the mill's own cook solids.
Foaming
Foam causes cavitation at the pump, unstable film transfer and pinholing. Defoamer content in the formulation is a trade-off: enough to control foam, not so much that it creates craters or interferes with a later coating layer. Ask for foaming tendency data at the mill's concentration and water hardness, and for the recommended additional defoamer route if control is needed.
Shear stability
Emulsion grades meet shear in transfer pumps, high-pressure filters and recirculation loops. Shear-induced coagulation appears as grit on the sheet, blocked filters and deposits on the size press. Ask how shear stability was determined and at what shear rate the grade was tested. A described test method is more useful than an adjective such as "shear resistant".
Process fit: acidic, neutral and alkaline papermaking
In acidic systems, rosin sizing with alum provides internal hydrophobicity, while surface sizing at the size press remains a separate operation that adds surface strength, print quality and surface water resistance. An anionic surface sizing agent can operate in this configuration, but it does not correct an internal sizing deficiency, and the alum load in the white water changes the charge environment that the surface size has to tolerate.
In neutral and alkaline systems, internal sizing is normally based on AKD or ASA. AKD is a reactive size that must be retained on the fibre and allowed a curing period before full hydrophobicity develops; ASA is emulsified close to the machine and dosed promptly. Both leave the size press to do a different job: film strength, surface smoothness, print definition and surface water resistance. For board and packaging grades, the two decisions are usually taken together, because internal sizing sets through-sheet water resistance while surface sizing sets printability and surface strength.
- If the mill runs rosin-alum internal sizing, treat the surface sizing grade as an addition to an acidic wet end and confirm pH tolerance and charge compatibility first.
- If the mill runs AKD or ASA internally, confirm that the surface grade does not interfere with size retention or with the curing behaviour of the reactive size.
- If the target requires through-sheet barrier performance, surface sizing alone is not a substitute for adequate internal sizing or for a dedicated barrier coating.
- If the target is print quality and surface strength, internal sizing alone will not deliver it.
JH-325's anionic styrene-acrylic identity places it on the anionic side of this map. For JH-600 and JH-WH3364, the position has to come from the supplier's written pH window, ionic character and recommended addition point, not from inference.
Can JH-WH3364 replace a separate AKD emulsion and SAE?
It can replace a two-product purchase only when it satisfies both jobs in the mill: internal through-sheet hydrophobicity at the target Cobb value, and surface performance at the target grade specification, at equal or lower total active dosage, with no new deposits, foam or retention problems. None of those conditions is established by a product description. Each is established by a split-run trial on the machine that will run the grade.
Three tests therefore have to pass together. The first is functional equivalence on both axes, measured separately rather than inferred from a combined figure. The second is dosage and cost accounting on a dry-on-dry basis, including any change in defoamer, retention aid or starch consumption that the composite makes necessary. The third is compatibility and stability: storage behaviour, dilution stability, interaction with the starch system and with whatever internal size remains in use elsewhere in the mill.
| Decision dimension | Two-product route (AKD plus SAE) | Single composite route | What settles it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Control of internal versus surface performance | Adjustable independently | Coupled through one product and one dosage | Separate Cobb and surface-strength measurements in the trial |
| Addition points and charge management | Two feed points, charge managed separately | Fewer feed points, one combined charge contribution | Deposit, retention and filter-pressure monitoring |
| Inventory and lot traceability | Two silos, two lot trails | One silo, one lot trail | Warehouse and QC plan agreed in advance |
| Troubleshooting granularity | Faults attributable to one function | Faults coupled across both functions | Reel-by-reel trend data during the trial |
| Compliance documentation | Two TDS and SDS sets | One set covering both functions | Market-specific and food-contact review per formulation |
| Cost accounting | Two invoices, two dosage figures | One invoice, one dosage figure | Cost per ton of paper at fixed quality targets |
Some conditions make the composite route harder to qualify: target grades that span a wide Cobb range and need independent tuning of internal and surface performance; furnishes that change seasonally and require performance to be rebalanced on different schedules; food-contact grades where each chemistry needs its own documentation; and sites with a single available addition point and no room for a clean trial leg. JHDA's stated development approach, building formulations around pulp composition, machine conditions, finished-paper requirements and seasonal variation, is relevant here, because a composite replacement is only defensible when it is tuned to the mill's furnish rather than adopted as a catalogue swap.
The side-by-side acceptance criteria checklist
A three-way decision can be closed with one checklist applied identically to JH-600, JH-325 and JH-WH3364. Nothing is accepted verbally, and nothing is accepted on a comparative claim alone.
| Group | Accept only when the supplier provides |
|---|---|
| Documents | TDS with test methods; SDS in GHS format; lot certificate of analysis; ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 certificates with scope; SGS or equivalent compliance report with report number; CAS numbers; IMDG transport documentation |
| Technical data | Total and active solids with method; pH on concentrate and at use dilution; viscosity curve with temperature, spindle and speed; ionic character; density; shelf life and storage temperature range; freeze-thaw and settling behaviour |
| Process data | Recommended dosage range and addition point; dilution water specification; compatibility with the mill's starch type; compatibility with the internal size in use; foaming tendency; shear test method; defoamer recommendation; cleaning and changeover procedure |
| Performance | Agreed target values for Cobb at 60 s and, where relevant, 180 s; surface strength by wax pick or IGT; internal bond; ring crush; burst; brightness; print mottle, all measured on the mill's own furnish |
| Commercial | MOQ (documented at 1 MT for JHDA), packaging, Incoterm, lead time in writing, sample and trial support, product-family capacity and utilisation, and a named technical contact for on-site commissioning |
Trial design: how to settle the choice in one machine run
A trial that cannot fail is not a trial. The design that settles a three-way surface sizing question is an A-B-A or A-B-C-A sequence on the same machine, same grade and same furnish, with dosage converted to a dry-on-dry basis and each leg run long enough to reach steady state and cover at least one reel change.
Measurements should be agreed before the first leg starts: Cobb at 60 s and 180 s, surface strength, internal bond, ring crush, burst, brightness, ash and moisture on the finished sheet, plus retention, machine speed, steam consumption, breaks, foam observations and filter pressure. Where a composite grade is on trial, internal and surface performance must be recorded as separate results, because a combined pass can hide a failure on one axis. Where the mill runs both recycled and virgin furnishes, at least one leg should run on the furnish that is hardest to size.
Acceptance should be written as a rule, not a feeling: a defined number of consecutive reels within specification on every agreed measure, with no increase in breaks or deposits. A single-reel demonstration or a laboratory result from another mill does not satisfy that rule, and neither does a comparison against a competitor's published figure.
Commercial, documentation and supply checks
Commercial terms are part of the technical decision, because a grade that cannot be delivered with consistent documents cannot be qualified in a regulated market. JHDA states that export orders are supported with commercial invoice, packing list, certificate of origin, pre-shipment inspection report, MSDS, TDS and dangerous goods transport documentation, and that payment terms include sight L/C, T/T and DP for large-volume orders. The company also states that factory audit visits are supported for distributors and end users.
Two supply points deserve a direct question rather than an assumption. First, published company-wide capacity statements on different company sources are not consistent and are not broken out by product family, so product-level capacity, line allocation and utilisation should be requested in writing before a contract depends on them. Second, the company describes a large central R&D laboratory as under construction rather than completed, which matters only if the mill expects formulation development work inside that facility rather than in the existing laboratory.
Delivery geography is documented: an overseas supporting production entity, CRM Chemical Technology Co., Ltd., operates in Long An Province, Vietnam, for ASEAN delivery, and core export markets are listed across Vietnam, Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia, Myanmar, Cambodia and packaging paper zones in the Middle East. Field technical service is described as on-site machine debugging covering Cobb, ring crush, bursting strength, brightness, fibre retention and runnability, which is the practical place where a surface sizing trial is usually won or lost.
Company details, the full product portfolio and current documentation are published by Qingzhou Jinhao New Material Co., Ltd., and the corporate brochure is available for download at the JHDA introduction brochure.
Market context: what the numbers do and do not say
Market scale explains why supplier evidence varies so much by tier. Global Market Insights valued the global sizing agents market at USD 2.98 billion in 2025, progressing to USD 3.1 billion in 2026, and estimated Kemira at 12% of that market in 2025, with the top five players holding 48% between them. Fact.MR put the alkyl ketene dimer segment at USD 860 million in 2026, with standard AKD emulsions at 54% of the AKD grade mix and a forecast 5.4% CAGR for China over 2026 to 2036. Calculated from the two cited values, the AKD segment represents roughly 27.7% of total sizing agent market value. Paper sizing agents excluding starch-based products are commonly classified under HS 3809.92.
The interpretation matters more than the totals. Concentration at the top of the market means brand-level data is easy to find and grade-level data is not, which is exactly why the mill's own trial remains the decisive document in a three-grade shortlist. The continued dominance of standard AKD emulsions also suggests that internal alkaline sizing remains the baseline against which surface sizing and composite routes are judged, rather than a step that a surface product replaces by default. Both readings are interpretation, not measurement, and neither substitutes for a trial result on a specific machine.
FAQ
How should a mill compare JH-600, JH-325 and JH-WH3364 when published values are incomplete?
Request the same document set from all three grades in identical format, then convert every figure to a common basis: total and active solids with method, pH at use dilution, viscosity with temperature and spindle, dosage on a dry-on-dry basis. Compare only values measured under matching conditions. Where a value is missing, record it as missing rather than substituting a general industry figure.
Which parameters matter most for acidic, neutral or alkaline systems?
In acidic rosin-alum systems, pH tolerance and charge compatibility come first, because the alum load changes the white-water charge environment. In neutral and alkaline systems running AKD or ASA, compatibility with the reactive size and its curing behaviour comes first, followed by starch compatibility at the size press. In every case, ionic character determines what can share a feed line: an anionic grade such as JH-325 should not be combined with strongly cationic additions.
Can JH-WH3364 replace separate AKD emulsion and SAE purchases?
Only after it demonstrates both functions in the mill: through-sheet hydrophobicity at the target Cobb and surface performance at the target grade specification, at equal or lower total active dosage, without new deposits, foam or retention losses. The replacement is a trial outcome, not a catalogue statement, and it should be accepted only against pre-agreed pass criteria on separate internal and surface measurements.
What trial design proves equivalence before switching?
An A-B-A or A-B-C-A sequence on the same machine, grade and furnish, with steady-state legs covering at least one reel change each, dosage on a dry-on-dry basis, and agreed measurements for Cobb, surface strength, internal bond, ring crush, burst, retention, steam and runnability. Acceptance should require a defined number of consecutive compliant reels with no increase in breaks or deposits.
What documents and commercial terms should be settled before qualification?
Settle TDS with test methods, SDS in GHS format, lot certificates of analysis, ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 certificates with scope, an SGS or equivalent compliance report with report number, CAS numbers and IMDG transport documents. Commercially, fix MOQ, packaging, Incoterm, lead time, sample and trial support, and product-family capacity in writing before the grade enters a contract.
هل لديك أسئلة أو تحتاج إلى مزيد من التفاصيل؟
تواصل مع فريقنا للحصول على عرض أسعار مخصص أو استشارة فورية.
طلب عرض أسعار
املأ النموذج أدناه وسيتواصل معك فريقنا بعرض مقترح مخصص.
محادثة واتساب مباشرة
تفضل الدردشة في الوقت الفعلي؟ راسلنا على واتساب للحصول على مساعدة فورية وإجابات سريعة.
- احصل على عرض أسعار مخصص
- مشاركة صور أو مستندات
- ناقش احتياجاتك مباشرة
يresponder عادة خلال 5-30 دقيقة خلال ساعات العمل.
